Saddle Search

Now that I had a proper fit guide for a saddle, the search was on. While we had been trying saddles, the fitter, J (I’d put her full name in the blog but I didn’t ask. If anyone wants to contact her for a fit, I’ll happily give you her information. She’s fantastic) had gone through all of the used saddles within Stubben’s database to see if there was anything that would work. Unfortunately, she wasn’t able to find anything. That meant it was time to take the search to the internet.

J said she would continue to look as well and if I found something I thought might be a possibility, to send the link to her so that she could tell me if it would work or not. Armed with the specifics from the saddle fitting, I started my search. There are a lot of saddles online. There are not a lot of 18″ seats online. There are even fewer that are narrow and less of those that fit into my price range. $1500 was as much as I could go and even then I felt iffy about it. That is a lot of money for when I’m not doing anything specific with Scarlet. I can justify a jump saddle because that is what I do for fun but nothing expensive because I’m not showing or training to show.

J found a Stubben Zaria online that fit the specifications but was exactly $1500. Since she found that around day one or two of searching, I didn’t want to jump on it. There could be other options within my price range but lower that would show up someday in the search. There are a lot of old saddles being sold online. A surprising amount of old saddles. Unfortunately, those were what was most in my price range. I looked through ebay and three different fb tack groups. There were a couple but either they were too expensive or too wide.

J spoke to one of the used tack stores here in town and they had an M. Toulouse with an 18″ seat for $1250. It had an adjustable gullet so I could make it as narrow as necessary to fit Scarlet. Since it was in town, I was able to do a trail without paying a fee for it or needing to purchase it entirely before trying it. I picked it up during my lunch hour and it was gorgeous. The tack store owner showed me how to adjust the gullet. It was really simple and very sturdy hardware. I also popped over to Mary’s to get some leather stirrups. I knew matching a saddle I was only trying out was silly but I needed leather ones anyway for this trial and future ones. Having a Wintec AP saddle meant that my stirrup leathers were synthetic and that is a no-go for actual leather saddles.

I was really excited to try it out and headed out to the barn. I tried it on without the saddle pad first and adjusted the saddle down a lot to make it nice and narrow. I had no idea if I got it right or not but I think it was okay. I had asked for a lot of pointers on how to test fit myself during the fitting so I felt confident enough to say I got it okay.

Unfortunately, as soon as I hopped on it felt off. The saddle fit funky underneath my butt. I thought it might just be me not being used to having a new saddle and walked for a while in it. It still felt odd but I decided to trot. A few steps in and it was like a stop sign came out of nowhere and hit me in the face. It was rubbing at the junction of my thigh and butt. I checked my breeches to make sure they hadn’t bunched up, checked my stirrups to make sure they weren’t interfering and no good. It just fit me wrong.

To say I was sad would have been an understatement. The saddle was gorgeous and the adjustable gullet would have made it super easy to transfer to Future Horse whenever they came around. So I returned it to the tack store and resigned myself to searching more.

Next time on The Horse Dream: Saddle Search – Part 2


12 thoughts on “Saddle Search

  1. I used a stubben fitter to find my saddle and was thrilled with the results. It took a few weeks for me to find it (and we had to wait for the Stubben Holiday sale!) but I ended up getting one that works for me. I could not get a 18 inch though. I wanted one but i needed the tree size for Remus more than I needed an 18 inch. The stubbens are big even in 17.5 and that is what i got and there is plenty of room for me 😉 HA! I like the double flapped Zaria a lot (Though I ended up spending WAY Too much for a monoflap instead….but am happy I did). And the Roxane is very comfy too. You can sometimes find them for a steal so keep looking!!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I actually tried out a 17.5 when i was working with the fitter. It definitely was too small for me. She said I could even go to 18.5 and still be good. They are nice and comfy though!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Good luck with the search. It is really nice that you have a fitter willing to work with multiple brands. I tried a M. Toulouse saddle one time a long time ago, it was a dressage saddle, and adored the adjustable gullet and the leather was so nice. But something was off with the fit for me and it made my hips scream and rubbed me odd.

    Liked by 1 person

    • The rubbing really threw me off. I was so confused too. I’ve never had a saddle rub me there and the seat didn’t look any different from other saddles.

      The fitter is definitely worth it. I have zero idea of how to fit a saddle on my own and she has been working so much to try and find saddles online for me.


  3. I hated trying saddles because I wasn’t sure what options I like/dislike. Trainer J told me that I’d know the second I sat in one I couldn’t deal with and she was right. Good luck with the search!

    Liked by 1 person

    • If I was going by instinct like that, I would have bought the saddle I sat in for the fitting. Wasn’t in my budget though. I think I would have needed at least 1000 more to make that saddle work.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s